It’s Time to Clean the Augean Stables

Nigel Scott avatar

·

·

3 minutes of reading

·

7 comments on It’s Time to Clean the Augean Stables

The Liberal Democrats have failed to adhere to liberal values again. Those responsible should go says Nigel Scott.

Share

Brown horses sticking their heads out of stable windows on a sunny day.

Natalie Bird was vilified for wearing a T-shirt with a slogan bearing the dictionary definition of ‘woman’. She was banned from standing as a candidate and suspended from the party. She took the party to court and won.

John Tilley is the former leader of Kingston Council. He was subjected to an internal party discipline hearing for objecting to a proposal that conference attendees should be required to wear badges stating their preferred pronouns. He wrote that there were more important matters that required our attention. He was sentenced to a ten year ban on holding party office or standing as a candidate. He appealed and the ruling was dismissed.

The adjudicator who overruled the panel’s verdict and decided in John’s favour was then removed herself.

Equality? No thanks we’re LibDems

The party’s “definition of transphobia”, which was partly plagiarised from the international definition of anti-Semitism, had to be amended because it was internally incoherent and conflicted with the requirements of the Equality Act, (which the party had supported as a bill during its passage through parliament).

Simon Jones, also known as Sabir, is a Muslim, a former Liberal Democrat councillor and a successful organiser and campaigner, who had reservations about the party’s policy on allowing trans identifying boys to use girls’ school bathrooms. 

He agreed to keep his concerns to himself, but nevertheless his party membership was suspended and he was banned from standing as a candidate. He was ordered to subject himself to re-education by a company called Midas Training, to correct his unacceptable views and realign himself with party thinking. 

A conflict of interest?

Midas Training is private company that is run by Candy Piercy and members of her family. It provides services to Sarah Green MP and was the subject of a Times investigation in 2024 where it was alleged it was paid £120,000 from Ms Green’s parliamentary expenses.

The woman’s rights group, Liberal Voice for Women was denied a stall at the party’s conference until it paid for legal advice confirming that this exclusion was unlawful. The party was forced to back down and the group is now able to exhibit at conference.

Christians awake

David Campanale is distinguished journalist and Christian who was to have been the party’s parliamentary candidate in Sutton and Cheam in the 2024 general election. He was “mocked and abused” for his religious beliefs and was removed and replaced by Luke Taylor, who was subsequently elected. 

In a signed declaration the party has admitted to several counts of unlawful religious discrimination and agreed to pay damages to Mr Campanale. According to the Daily Telegraph, the bill is expected to exceed £250,000.

The above cases are the tip of the iceberg. There are many more.

It’s time to get a grip

Average party members should be shocked by what is being done in their name. This behaviour is no longer an aberration, it has become ingrained and is the new normal.

It is past time for accountability. It is not acceptable to shovel thousands of pounds of hard earned member donations to lawyers as the party seeks and fails to defend the indefensible. 

It is time for those responsible to step aside and allow the party to be run by liberals again. It is in the name, after all. 

Share

Comments

7 responses to “It’s Time to Clean the Augean Stables”

  1. Richard E Kirker avatar
    Richard E Kirker

    Do add more of the examples please. Each one needs to be recorded lest we forget the sacrifices the persecuted endured. We owe every one of them our respect and gratitude.

    1. Juliet Chaplin avatar
      Juliet Chaplin

      This is an appalling story and indeed surely all those responsible should go. They should also themselves pay the damages, in my view.

      This is the kind of attitude which is destroying our country. The more we co-operate, within this country and with others, the better for everyone. Respect for others and tolerance for others’ views is a basic requirement.

  2. Zoe Hollowood avatar
    Zoe Hollowood

    Thank you Nigel for this succinct review of many recent cases of discrimination in the Lib Dems caused by illiberal activists who have their hands on too many levers of power. This is combined with abuse of the opaque internal complaints process (which also contains too many activists at the helm as evidenced by the ousting of an adjudicator who effectively stood up for John Tilly by rightly referring the original decision to appeal).

  3. Andrew MacGregor avatar
    Andrew MacGregor

    Other examples include Alison Jenner – deselected as a sitting councillor for promoting women’s rights. Alison Eden who has been taken through lots of complaints because of one gentle article she wrote then her stance on women’s rights.

  4. Yonni Wilson avatar
    Yonni Wilson

    Is this why our party is languishing at the bottom of opinion polls – despite our position as 3rd party, with 72 MPs..?!

    Blowing all that time, energy, members’ fees & donations on defending the umpteen & endless indefensible discrimination claims?!

    The LibDem leadership is squandering the perfect opportunity to assume the position of mission-led centrist party, offering serious leadership, ready to resolve ordinary voters’ real-life challenges – instead, careering from one debacle to another clown-show, unable or unwilling to rid itself of the unhinged extremist minority who’ve grabbed a stranglehold on control of the party.

    How can it be that our membership has halved?!
    ..said nobody ever.

  5. Mohammed Amin avatar
    Mohammed Amin

    Thank you for listing these cases. Please add more if you become aware of them.

    There is extreme intolerance practiced by some within our party, who are unwilling to accept that people could hold different views on sex, gender, religion, etc. from themselves.

  6. Kayed Al-Haddad avatar
    Kayed Al-Haddad

    They should be ashamed to call themselves ‘Liberal’!

    People should consider joining The Liberal Party instead; far more Liberal and indeed radical.

Leave a Reply

Comments are reviewed before publication. You will receive a notification by email when your comment is approved. Contributions that breach our guidelines will not be published. See our Comment Policy.

To display a profile photo next to your comments, register your email address with Gravatar.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *